Tent advice

[Roadtonowhere]

I've never worried too much about gear weight but I'm getting older and have some mild knee and back issues that mean I am looking for a lighter tent suitable for solo walking (30%), or walking with a partner (70%) in Tasmania.

I have read the forums here, done my own research and found myself at the following point. Any advice would be appreciated.....

Tarptent Scarp 2 - looks like a good option without going super light and compromising durability too much. The Double Rainbow looks like it would be cramped for two people. From what I read here, I would not need the optional cross poles. Would it be best to get the solid inner rather than mesh inner?

Big Sky Revolution 2 - can get locally rather than from US. Freestanding which I like and similar weight to Scarp 2. External pole system. Can only get mesh inner at moment so not sure if that presents an issue in colder weather. I've always had solid inners.

Durston x mid 2 - lighter than above two, but I would need to buy the optional poles as I don't use trekking poles. Looks more awkward to set up and not sure if it is getting a bit too minimalist.

Other - Mont Moondance is a great tent but getting up there in weight. The S2S Telos seems overpriced but I am open to convincing. Nemo tents seem cramped and have very low hydrostatic heads for the floors.

[crollsurf]

My choice would be:
1. Durston because its ~500g lighter, has a great rep, and I'm not a fan of tent poles. It needs trekking poles (or custom) which adds weight, but at least you're not having to phaff around threading the damn things through sleeves.

2.Scarp 2. The Scarp is bomber, so you'll feel more confident in really bad weather. Plus Tarptent has a reputation, second to none

I don't really know Big Sky other than some UL gear they sell. I'd like a bit more vestibule space for shoes, cooking in bad weather etc

[Warin]

Getting older with knee problems, and not using trekking poles? Get the trekking poles, your knees will thank you. I use cheap ebay ones ~$70 a pair...

[Mark7260]

FWIW,
I have just replaced my X Mid with a Mont Moondance 1. The X Mid is a fine tent, I can put it up in under 60 seconds, handles rain and light snow and the polyester fly is a dream.
It doesn't do well if the ground isn't flat. Especially if there is any amount of wind.
I am doing much more offtrack stuff now and rarely have found myself camping on ideal sites. To complicate matters further, if your on coral fern or worse, then the trekking pole, or the Z Flicks become a problem. As for weight, by the time you add the proper amount of stakes and guy lines then there really isn't much in it.
The Mont Moondance isn't perfect either, the vestibule is a little small, but the interior is ample.

[Roadtonowhere]

Warin. I do a lot of off track walking and find poles to be more of an issue than a help.

[Roadtonowhere]

FWIW,
I have just replaced my X Mid with a Mont Moondance 1. The X Mid is a fine tent, I can put it up in under 60 seconds, handles rain and light snow and the polyester fly is a dream.
It doesn't do well if the ground isn't flat. Especially if there is any amount of wind.
I am doing much more offtrack stuff now and rarely have found myself camping on ideal sites. To complicate matters further, if your on coral fern or worse, then the trekking pole, or the Z Flicks become a problem. As for weight, by the time you add the proper amount of stakes and guy lines then there really isn't much in it.
The Mont Moondance isn't perfect either, the vestibule is a little small, but the interior is ample.

Thanks Mark, that is really helpful advice as a lot of my camping is in off track areas.

[Roadtonowhere]

My choice would be:
1. Durston because its ~500g lighter, has a great rep, and I'm not a fan of tent poles. It needs trekking poles (or custom) which adds weight, but at least you're not having to phaff around threading the damn things through sleeves.

2.Scarp 2. The Scarp is bomber, so you'll feel more confident in really bad weather. Plus Tarptent has a reputation, second to none

I don't really know Big Sky other than some UL gear they sell. I'd like a bit more vestibule space for shoes, cooking in bad weather etc

Thanks. I think the extra capability of the tarptent is a strong attraction.

[rcaffin]

but at least you're not having to phaff around threading the damn things [p0oles] through sleeves.

Funny about that - having threaded four poles into their sleeves in a 100 kph snow storm (NOT kidding!), I have to say the process went smoothly and was even reassuring.
We had a good night.
(Mt Anton, winter, zero visibility, and yes, 100 kph.)

MainRange6.jpg (58.92 KiB) Viewed 9091 times

(Not Mt Anton but the morning before it. No point taking a photo of a wall of white.)

Cheers
Roger

[JohnnoMcJohnno]

I like my Scarp 2 but it doesn't feel particularly solid without the crossing poles, which puts its weight up there with the Monts and many other tents. Also, and for what it's worth, every Tarptent I have ever bought ends up weighing at least 100g more than list because you will need to seam seal it and add a few pegs and guys. Doesn't mean you shouldn't buy one though, just something to bear in mind. If you are happy with single skin, the Tarptent Cloudburst with the optional 3rd pole has plenty of room, is lighter than the Scarp 2 with X-poles, and feels very robust. 2 of the poles are sleeved but it's much less phaffing around than the Scarp X-poles. Won't be much good if it snows though.

No experience with Monts, Big Sky's or X-mids. I do have a 2 man Nemo Firefly but I wouldn't recommend it for Tassie and I feel it's really a 1 & 1/2 man tent anyway. Good luck with your choices.

[headwerkn]

Double Rainbow is definitely on the more spacious side of 2pp tents - fits two 25" wide pads - and is perfectly comfortable for a couple unless you're both super tall. It is a bit narrower up at the top than say a Scarp, Stratospire or Dipole though. Usually we take turns in getting dressed

That said we've gone with the Dipole 2 for its replacement: mostly for (hopefully) improved ventilation and bigger vestibules, and partly for a little extra floor length and head height.

[Roadtonowhere]

I like my Scarp 2 but it doesn't feel particularly solid without the crossing poles, which puts its weight up there with the Monts and many other tents. Also, and for what it's worth, every Tarptent I have ever bought ends up weighing at least 100g more than list because you will need to seam seal it and add a few pegs and guys. Doesn't mean you shouldn't buy one though, just something to bear in mind. If you are happy with single skin, the Tarptent Cloudburst with the optional 3rd pole has plenty of room, is lighter than the Scarp 2 with X-poles, and feels very robust. 2 of the poles are sleeved but it's much less phaffing around than the Scarp X-poles. Won't be much good if it snows though.

No experience with Monts, Big Sky's or X-mids. I do have a 2 man Nemo Firefly but I wouldn't recommend it for Tassie and I feel it's really a 1 & 1/2 man tent anyway. Good luck with your choices.

Thanks Johnno. As you say, if the cross bars are needed it is really not much different to a Mont.

[Roadtonowhere]

Double Rainbow is definitely on the more spacious side of 2pp tents - fits two 25" wide pads - and is perfectly comfortable for a couple unless you're both super tall. It is a bit narrower up at the top than say a Scarp, Stratospire or Dipole though. Usually we take turns in getting dressed

That said we've gone with the Dipole 2 for its replacement: mostly for (hopefully) improved ventilation and bigger vestibules, and partly for a little extra floor length and head height.

How did you find the shipping? Reasonably quick or slow?

[WalkerWade]

I just bought a Tarptent scarp1 in Nov and it arrived in Perth WA in just over a week.

[headwerkn]

How did you find the shipping? Reasonably quick or slow?

Terrible... been stuck in CA since the 15th and no updates from USPS since :-/ Don't know if it is still there or gonna suddenly appear on my desk tomorrow.

Our first tent got here within a week (pre COVID). Second, in 2021, took a month and went via Japan for reasons unexplainable by modern science or transport logistics...

[Roadtonowhere]

Looks like a bit of a lottery but I am not in an urgent rush so up to 4 weeks is tolerable.

[Franco]

As for the Scarp 2...
The X poles are mostly for snow loading. IF you peg out the corners as they should and use the main pole guylines, it works for most like that .
I would suggest the solid inner . Mesh is nicer in the warmest weather but the solid works better when windy or cool/cold.

this is a different type of that corner but the idea is the same. Pull the two struts ,spread out , towards you , plant them spread out and keep them there with one hand as you insert the peg with the tie outs fully extended with the other hand.
Many just sit the two struts and then try to get the tension by pulling those tie outs in. Better do it the other way....

[bearded bushwalker]

USPS tracking for Tarptent seems to only go to CA. Copy and paste the tracking number into an international parcel tracker such as parcelsapp.com and all of a sudden you get a clearer account of your parcels journey.

[headwerkn]

USPS tracking for Tarptent seems to only go to CA. Copy and paste the tracking number into an international parcel tracker such as parcelsapp.com and all of a sudden you get a clearer account of your parcels journey.

Legend! As suspected, it's somewhere between Melbourne and here. Actually looks like it's been there since the 22nd :-/ Freakin' Aramax...

[Jack Doolan]

Legend! As suspected, it's somewhere between Melbourne and here. Actually looks like it's been there since the 22nd :-/ Freakin' Aramax...[/quote]

I have it on good authority that Aramax just invested in a fleet of Penny Farthings. Your delivery may only be a matter of years away.

[bernieq]

Did you look at Wilderness Equipment 1st or 2nd Arrow? I have both as well as Tarptent Scarp1 (& DW Moment). All are great tents; solid & well designed. I've used all in Tassie & NZ-SI in some seriously bad wx.

The 1stA is a spacious 2P tunnel tent with a really useful front vestibule (gear storage, cooking in rubbish wx). The 2ndA can just fit 2P & has a smaller but still useful front vestibule.

Considering space, rain, wind, snow (but not weight, price), I'd rank them : 1stA, 2ndA, Scarp2

[Roadtonowhere]

I prefer tents with dual entrances, especially when sharing. I do have a minaret at home for when I really need something bombproof

[Biggles]

I prefer tents with dual entrances, especially when sharing. I do have a minaret at home for when I really need something bombproof

The sunflower yellow Minaret certainly is unflappable!
I used mine confidently this week at Pretty Valley just at the time the weather turned well and truly belly-up from Wednesday: pea-soupers, horizontal and pelting rain, flooding, wind, one electrical storm after another...rinse and repeat!

MacPac's DuoLite (2.15kg complete) has dual entrances and vestibules, albeit not luxuriously room vestibules, but enough for a pack and boots; it is a tad lighter than the Minaret and has less bulk when packed; I use it with Toaks Ti pegs (as for the Moondance and Minaret also). Bulk can be cut down by using a compression sack, other than the simple affair provided with these tents.

[Roadtonowhere]

I have a friend with a duolight and it is a good option.