keithy wrote:
Just my opinion.
I was quite a fan of Macpac clothing - I still have an older softshell that was my goto travel jacket bought in 2005 and used well into 2011. Still have it a spare jacket but it is showing it's wear now and the collar doesn't stay propped up. And I also still have a nice Gore windstopper fleece jacket I bought around 2006 that was good for car camping. I recommended Macpac to a friend who was after a good rain jacket and they had issues with the DWR within a year. He wasn't that happy as it wasn't a cheap jacket.
I'm not sure what happened to the company since although I'd heard they sold it and production is all done in the Far East (China / Vietnam / Phillipines). Where it's made is not a problem for me, as long as the QC is there.
I still like looking at Macpac stuff - my last trip to NZ in 2012 I went had had a look at a few Macpac stores and their gear looking for a replacement softshell and a pack. I noticed that stitching quality was different between two samples of the same jacket, and the sizing was bigger than previous models. For their regular (non-sale) prices, there seem to be other options.
To me they seem to have become more like Kathmandu - I mean, early last year I sold an older style long length Kathmandu jacket that was made in NZ. It was bought a long time ago, but didn't get a lot of use as I couldn't get used to the longer over thigh fit. Still, it was quite a bullet proof jacket for it's price back then. But these days I would recommend people look elsewhere for a hardshell jacket first.
I haven't used Macpac's tents or sleeping bags though, so my comments were really on the clothing.
The reason I posted this down sale is that the prices for the product seem good in comparison with other down products out there now.
Ahh its funny how we are all a bit different.
I struggled to settle on a raincoat as my preference is for a long one.
I went with a Reflex model (Copeland I think) as I wasn't happy with the length or venting in any of the Event ones.
I've read of lots of different brand event jackets failing to impress long term due to higher maintenance issues.
I figure if I'm going to be moving in above 10 degrees, I'm going to be damp from perspiration anyway.
I use a very well vented event jacket from Showers Pass for cycling which I like but I really wanted a coat for walking in.
I grabbed some pertex Resolution pants but have yet to use them in the wet so can't yet report on my thoughts.
I'm very happy so far with the Copeland with the caveat that I expect to be damp (from sweat) but warm.
I got excellent longevity with high use from my last reflex rainwear.
Extremely happy with my warm Macpac sleeping bags and tents that have proved weather proof.
Like all brands they have their strengths and compromises but my gear has largely proved suitable for my use and I'm happy with my choices.
This isn't stated to in any way deny your own experience or deride your opinion as there is plenty of learning to be had from others experience and opinions in my view.
Reading your post, I shall now pay close attention to stitching in any of the clothing I purchase in future.
Thanks for sharing your experience.