Robi wrote:Sorry to show my lack of knowledge. However, I wondering where garmin devices fit into rescues. Are spot, garmin and plb signals all treated the same way? Any recommnedations on the best source to find out?
I
'think' how it works is the following
SPOT and Garmin Inreach : On Emergency activation the signal goes via satelite to a 24/7 private rescue organisation. Usually its
https://www.geosresponse.com/ The private rescue org communicates with you via your device (if possible) and contacts the closest offical SAR co-ordintion agency to your postion for search and rescue.The SAR agency will activate and dispatch search and rescue services to you.
PLBs: On emergency activation the signal gets sent via satelite to an automated base station which routes it the closest offical (government) SAR co-ordintion agency to your postion. The SAR agency will activate and dispatch search and rescuse services to you
Regarding the actual radio signal. Thats a bit more complicated.
Generally speaking a PLB sos activation signal has a higher chance of being picked up quicker as they use the global coverage COSPAS SARSAT satelite network thats has geo stationary satelites, low earth orbit satelites and now medium altitude satelites (in a higher orbit). Upon PLB activation SAR SAT satelites provide the detection/routing to rescue serices and location fixing of the PLB. The SAR SAT network is a dedicated search and rescue satelite network/system.
http://www.cospas-sarsat.int/en/system- ... sat-systemGarmin uses the global coverage iridium satelite network for SOS and two way messaging.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_s ... stellationThese satelites are in a low earth orbit which could mean the SOS doesnt get picked up as fast as the PLB signal as there is greater chance of a low earth orbit line of sight to your device being interupted by a mountain or the curviture of the earth (of course if a iridium sat is directly above you or in your devices line of sight then it will get picked up right away)
The other challenge is that the iridium satelites dont offer a postion service. So your garmin device also needs to be in line of sight of a postion fixing satelite such as GPS. (as far as i know they cant use the SAR SAT satelites which have dual sos and postion fixing ability). Of course even if your garmin inreach cant find a GPS satelite you can still tell the private rescue service GEOs your location via the two way messgenger service. Spot uses a similar satelite network that used to be inferior to Garmins in terms of global coverage but im not sure if thats still the case.
One major advantage of most garmin/spot vs a PLB is that you can tell if your SOS activation has been received and help is on the way. (as the private rescuse org will msg you and provide medical info and rescue eta etc). If you dont receive acknowledgment then you know to move to a postion with a better line of sight to more sky. The private rescue org GEOS can also update search and rescue services on your condition and enviroment so SAR deploy the most appropriate assets for a quick and safe rescue.
With a PLB you activate and pray that your signal is getting through. (It probably is but if your down a steep valley it might take a few hours for a SAR SAT satelite to have line of sight to you) And you dont know if help is 3 hours or 13 hours away. If for example your bitten by a snake (where moving after being bitten is bad) then not knowing if the signal has gotten through could be very stressful and cause you to make a potentialy bad decision for your health. (like climbing to the top of the hill to get a better line of sight to the sky...with your movement reducing the time it takes for the venom to reach your vital organs)