Following on from a number of related threads, I thought I'd share how Meetup.com has worked for our bushwalking group.
[The site to which I am referring is http://www.meetup.com, not the Meet Up tool on this website.]
Overall, it's working really well.
Ages - seems to be from mid-50's down. I'm in my late 40's myself, and there's more in their mid-40's/late-30's, and a few in their 20's. I suspect it's due to the nature of the medium. It's those people who are online, or tech savvy, that find us.
Numbers - Last count, we were at 85 members. Of that, there's about 35 who've actually been on a walk last season.
On any given walk, we usually have about 12-15 people. Meetup allows limits to be set, and it also manages an automatic waiting list which is brilliant. e.g. if someone pulls out, the next in the queue gets an email to let them know they're in.
Signing on, we wanted to be very specific about who we'd like to walk with. Meetup allows you to list themes for your group. They're keywords to help with searching, and they give the prospective member a feel for what you're about. Obviously we listed 'bushwalking' and 'hiking', and we added 'Natural History' and a few others to give us the "flavour" we wanted.
We set our membership application to be approved by the organiser. (You can just let people sign up without this.) We also ask the question "There are a number of bushwalking groups in Perth, what in particular attracted you to this one?". This is designed to encourage members to read our themes and our intro, so they know what they're in for. It doesn't always work, by the way.
Events - are date and location based. Locations can be tricky as meetup tries to be specific about addresses. It doesn't easily lend itself to descriptions such as "turn left on Flynn Rd, then take the first track on the right and look for the clearing about 500m in". We manage by putting full directions and map links in the details.
Editing - the editor can be a bit clunky, especially formatting and adding web links. A little bit of HTML knowledge helps.
Repeating and copying events works well. It's an easy way to setup your own "template". Event templates themselves aren't a feature of meetup.
RSVPing - limits can be set for each event. Also the number of guests any one attendee can bring, and the time in which RSVP's can be made, e.g. 2 weeks before, up until 2 days before. This has helped reduce "booking hogs" who sign up for everything months in advance, holding out places for other (and new) members, and then don't turn up! Not that we've had many of those.
Reports - for any event, an attendee list can be printed. And name tags, if that's your thing. You can also get a list of who's shown up, who hasn't, and so on. Can export to Excel [which is handy for an MS Office guru like me.]
We prefer an active group, so I'm going to make an email list within meetup of all of those who have never attended, and send a message of encouragement. If we find there's members on that list for over 12 months, then a cull may be in order.
Security - so far, so good. Non-members can't email, or see photos, or RSVP to an event, as you'd expect. The level of access can be set by the organiser.
Communication - easily taken care of by Meetup. New events are announced (emailed), reminders are automatic, and personal email addresses remain secure. If members want to contact each other, they can do so via the site, and they can choose whether to show their personal email address with each message as it's sent. Reminders are set to 1 week and 1 day prior. The reminder dates are not customisable, but the message is.
Comments and feedback - are there for each event. We encourage members to use this to organise carpooling and the like. Feedback also helps prospective members get a feel for the group.
Organisers - can be whole of group, or just for an event.
Suggested events - can be done by any member, with or without organiser approval. We chose the organiser approval.
Forum - there is one, but we don't use it.
Cost - it's not free to be a 'host', i.e. set up your own meetup group. From memory, it's about $40 a quarter? But, to me, that's cheap enough for what you get. And you can charge your members per event to cover those costs. We choose not to, for now.
We've been on Meetup since April 2011, which is just the one season for us. For me, it's working well. It has its quirks, and things I'd like to see changed, but it's made my life easier, and I get to spend more time doing what I like doing - bushwalking!
PS - you'll find us herehttp://www.meetup.com/redtail-bushwalkers/. If you're heading to Perth, say g'day.