Strider wrote:How do you like it compared to the SS1, Dan?
Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk
Good question and one Ill probably be asking myself for a while but heres my thoughts so far.
SS1 Feels roomier inside perhaps due to its higher roof, it has far wider vestibules and they feel 'safer' to cook in etc due to the steepness of the walls.
Scarp has a smaller footprint. It 'should' be better in snow/wind. However I never had a problem with the SS1 or SS2 for that matter. The SS1 would shed snow ok (even though I never tested this) and it definitely handled wind ok if pitched properly.
However the Scarp is easier to pitch well for wind, so its possibly more user friendly in regards to not having to put too much thought into how you set up guy lines for instance. Where as the SS1 does require you to do a bit extra with guy lines to handle high winds.
One thing I didn't like about the scarp was the inners zip is designed the same on both sides so you need to sleep a certain way around if you want easy access to the vestibule. Where as the SS has the inners zippers offset and reversed on both sides so regardless of how or where its pitched you can choose a side that will give you easy access to the vestibule regardless of what way around you are sleeping. Sounds a bit petty and realistically its no big deal but its still something I noticed having pitched the tent on a slight slope (so obviously had my head up the higher end) and then realising the door on the inner didn't really open in a user friendly way for the way I had to sleep.
I think the scarp was condensating more than the SS would but its really difficult to be certain about this due to all the variables but maybe the higher roof in the SS worked better for this?
The scarps centre pole is a bit of pain to put in and take out but Im sure Ill tolerate that ok. But the SS in a lot of instances required me to have a couple of goes at getting the pegs in the ground in the right place where as the Scarp is easier to get right the first time.
Both have double entry, both can take a second mat if required but the SS does this better.
So at the end of the day Im happy with the Scarp due to its easier 4 season pitching and slightly smaller footprint but obviously it comes with some minor sacrifices over the SS.