surly 17 wrote:It's the rangers I feel sorry for most they have a hard enough time trying to do a great job under the threat of constant job cuts , being under resourced. I haven't met one who's not friendly and willing to give advice, now there going to have to deal with this total bull,,!?
Not meaning to start a flamewar, or invalidate your own experiences, but in the 4 years I've been in Vic, my experience with rangers has been utterly and universally the opposite. Officious, bureaucratic, pedantic, and ignorant about the very parks they're being paid to 'manage'. I offer one of many examples:
I did a hike in late June at the Prom, and an unpowered campsite for the first night at Tidal there was ~$53 for two people. Despite having hot showers and splitting the costs, I smarted at that. When we arrived, there was not a ranger to been seen. So we set ourselves up, and left the next morning at 8am, rangers stll absent, still unable to get our alread paid-for camping pass.
My hiking partner was a gutsy, but maybe a little ambitious, elderly man in his mid sixties, who was very keen on seeing the lighthouse, and confident we could make it out
and back to our planned camp at Roaring Meg. I wasn't so sure, but couldn't let him go on his own, and he was
going. So when we arrived at the lighthose on dusk, I explained the situation delicately to the Parks staff there, and politely asked if they could maybe make a one-off exception and let us camp in some out-of-the-way corner. We were given a blanket refusal, supposedly on the grounds that the weather could become unsafe .... When I pointed out it had been dead calm all day, I was lectured about how weather can change quickly out here, and condescendingly asked if I've even checked the BoM website. I said I didn't need to - I'd instead just phoned my old boss at the BoM office I worked at, and got a more specific local met package faxed to me. When I showed them this, outlining the massive high over SE Vic at the time and the forecast of no wind for 3 days they were unaware of, and gave them the direct number to the forecaster to verify any questions they might have, they told me they didn't have a phone, and the answer was still 'camp somewhere else'.
When pointed out that it was inconsitent (liability-wise) for them to refuse us camping on 'saftey' grounds based on an impossible outside chance of foul weather, yet they were happy to send a 66 year old man with a hip problem on an 8km hike back around the headland to the next campsite, on a cliffside track, at night, into said 'possible' bad weather, they 'generously' offered us one of the cabin rooms that had a no-show....at $133 a head, for hostel-style facilities. They couldn't phone the weather office to verify it was safe to camp, but they
could take a $266 payment by card..... We didn't have much choice. It wasn't a bad place to stay, but outrageously expensive, and there wa no wind that night - something I made sure to point out to them before leaving then next morning.
When we got back to Tidal river, we had a shower before driving home. Just after I left the shower block, I was bailed up by a ranger who'd finally bothered to show up to work, who reprimanded me for using the showers despite not being booked to stay that night. When I explaned that we'd already paid Parks Vic over $300 for two nights in their park and were now heading home, I was met with uncompromising pedantry, and a demand to visit the office to pay now for another night of 'camping' we wouldn't even use.
My patience ran out, and I told him (in perhaps slightly harsher terms) I would not pay, and that if he had a problem with that, he was welcome to take my licence plate and report the stolen hot water to the police. I am yet to recieve a summons.
Rangers are not police. They can
ask for your details, and use those to either issue you with an on-the-spot infrigement, or report you. But they cannot give you commands. They cannot make demands. They cannot detain you.
It's up to us, whether we let them enforce absurdities on us.